Chapter XIX: Conclusion

The Alliance put into Corunna, where Conyngham saw again representatives of the house of Roderigo, Hortalez and Company, and learned that the money received for the prizes had been forwarded to the commissioner’s agent at Paris.

Although he had been treated as an officer of the regular service by John Paul Jones, and had been summoned to attend a court-martial as such, Conyngham decided to return as soon as possible to his own country and sailed in the Experiment for Philadelphia. But most unfortunately his hard luck followed him. When but a few days on the voyage the vessel was captured by the British Admiral Edwards, and within three weeks Conyngham was back once more at Mill prison. But his treatment this time was very different from that which had been accorded him before; and though his spirit chafed at the delay and the confinement, still he was not forced to endure such bodily suffering. In prison, however, he stayed for the rest of the war, and upon his release returned to the United States.

Almost immediately he sought to have an inquiry made and an accounting rendered for his prize-money and reimbursement for his services, but owing to the condition of affairs that existed at that time it was difficult to get Congress to take any action. There was indeed but little money in the Treasury, and so he was forced to go upon a voyage in a merchant vessel, from which he returned to begin institution of his long suit against Congress for remuneration and redress. And now the tragedy of his life began. For year after year he prayed and petitioned Congress to listen to his plea. Before the matter came actually to trial, good Dr. Franklin was dead. Many witnesses could not be procured, and some of his earlier acquaintances and friends who had not behaved in good faith toward him now deserted him completely.

The missing commission would have proved his position, and the search for it became almost the business of his life. A voyage to Europe and a personal investigation of all clues failed to show any trace. It had disappeared as completely as if it had never existed--a fact which some of his enemies asserted to be the case.

In this chapter we print a facsimile of his petition to Congress, signed by himself and dated ten years after his first services were rendered. It shows how much hope he had, and yet there is a note almost of despair that rings throughout it. The claim was first submitted to Benjamin Walker by Alexander Hamilton, then at the head of the Treasury, and Mr. Walker failed to perceive any proof of Captain Conyngham’s having been a regularly appointed officer in the service, and for this reason recommended that the claim be not acknowledged. But yet we find him again in 1793 petitioning Alexander Hamilton for redress. In fact, to the day of his death he attempted in every way to have his claim, that he had left to the justice of his country, adjusted and closed up.

During the _quasi_ war with France, Conyngham commanded an armed brig named the Maria, and in the War of 1812 he again sought to go to sea, but his health prevented him taking an active part.

Conyngham died in Philadelphia, November 27, 1819, in the seventy-second year of his age, and was buried in St. Peter’s churchyard, and on his grave is an odd epitaph in the form of an acrostic built on the name “Gustavus.”

But now appears the strangest part of the whole story--one of those remarkable instances that so well prove the old adage of “facts being stranger than fiction.” It is the tragic epilogue to the play--the bitter end of the thread that runs through the whole of the relation. It does not take long to tell, and surely it speaks for itself.

Only a short time ago there appeared in the catalogue of M. Charavay, an autograph and print-seller in Paris, among hundreds of other notices, the following:

143 Hancock (John), celebre homme d’Etat américain,
gouverneur du Massachusetts, signataire de la Déclaration
de l’Indépendence,--Pièce signe comme président du congrès;
Baltimore, 1 mars 1777, 1 p. in-fol. obl. Rare.

The connection of names and dates of course would attract the attention of any collector. It would be seen that most possibly it had something to do with Franklin’s sojourn in France. It was only the price asked for John Hancock’s signature--in fact, much less than his signature usually brought in the autograph market--ten francs. But what was the joy and surprise of its present possessor, upon opening his new purchase, to find that it was nothing more nor less than the missing commission of the Surprise! Where it had been, what has been its history since it was delivered at Versailles, how it came at last into the possession of a little print-shop, no one can tell; but that it had much to do with the foregoing story any one can see. It lies before the author as he writes, and is reproduced in these pages for the first time, that the court of public print may decide the question. That bold Gustavus Conyngham was badly treated by his country and hardly handled by Fate the reader can perceive. He had helped the cause in the way it most needed help, but, notwithstanding, unrewarded, the man who flew the flag in the Channel went broken-hearted to his grave, and now out of the past, too late, comes the authentic proof of his cause and asseverations. The world is a small one and strange things happen in it, can be the only comment.

THE END

YOUNG HEROES OF OUR NAVY.

Uniform Edition. Each, 12mo, cloth, $1.00.

=Reuben James.=

A Hero of the Forecastle. By CYRUS TOWNSEND BRADY, author of “Paul Jones.” Illustrated by George Gibbs and others.

“Nothing could be more absorbing than Mr. Brady’s graphic
tale, which forms an eloquent tribute to the heroes of the
forecastle, the predecessors of the men who did such gallant
work at Manila and Santiago.”--_Cleveland World._

=The Hero of Manila.=

Dewey on the Mississippi and the Pacific. By ROSSITER JOHNSON. Illustrated by B. West Clinedinst and others.

“There is nothing sensational or bombastic in the story from
beginning to end. It is, however, picturesque and vivid, as
well as dignified, modest, and decidedly interesting.”--_Boston
Budget._

=The Hero Of Erie= (_Commodore Perry_).

By JAMES BARNES, author of “Midshipman Farragut,” “Commodore Bainbridge,” etc. With 10 full-page Illustrations.

=Commodore Bainbridge.=

From the Gunroom to the Quarter-deck. By JAMES BARNES. Illustrated by George Gibbs and others.

=Midshipman Farragut.=

By JAMES BARNES. Illustrated by Carlton F. Chapman.

=Decatur and Somers.=

By MOLLY ELLIOT SEAWELL. With 6 full-page Illustrations by J. O. Davidson and others.

=Paul Jones.=

By MOLLY ELLIOT SEAWELL. With 8 full-page Illustrations.

=Midshipman Paulding.=

A True Story of the War of 1812. By MOLLY ELLIOT SEAWELL. With 6 full-page Illustrations.

=Little Jarvis.=

The Story of the Heroic Midshipman of the Frigate Constellation. By MOLLY ELLIOT SEAWELL. With 6 full-page Illustrations.

APPLETONS’ SUPPLEMENTARY READERS.

Uncle Robert’s Geography.

By the late FRANCIS W. PARKER and NELLIE L. HELM. A Series of Geographical Readers for Supplementary Use. Three volumes. Illustrated. 12mo. Cloth.

1. Playtime and Seedtime 32 cents
2. On the Farm 42 ”
3. Uncle Robert’s Visit 50 ”

Uncle Robert teaches children how to read aright the great book of Nature. He makes study a pleasure. He teaches geography in the right way. He makes rural life and occupations attractive. He has a deep and loving sympathy with child-life. He believes in the education that strengthens the body as well as the mind. He tells children instructive stories to arouse their imaginations and stimulate their observing powers. He believes that every normal child may be made useful in the world. He has a boundless faith in human progress, and finds his greatest hopes in childhood and its possibilities.

=These extraordinarily suggestive little books by the late Colonel Parker--one of the most far-sighted students of child-life of our day--have approved themselves to thousands of primary teachers. They form one of the few successful attempts to incorporate that which is close by nature to child perception into the very warp and woof of the child mind. They give an intelligible meaning and vitality to the round of experiences that come to all normal children in our land.=

FOR NATURE-LOVERS AND ANGLERS.

Familiar Fish: Their Habits and Capture.

A Practical Book on Fresh-Water Game Fish. By EUGENE MCCARTHY. With an Introduction by Dr. David Starr Jordan, President of Leland Stanford Junior University, and numerous Illustrations. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

This informing and practical book describes in a most interesting fashion the habits and environment of our familiar freshwater game fish, including anadromous fish like the salmon and sea trout. The life of a fish is traced in a manner very interesting to nature-lovers, while the simple and useful explanations of the methods of angling for different fish will be appreciated by fishermen old and young. As one of the most experienced of American fishermen, Mr. McCarthy is able to speak with authority regarding salmon, trout, ouananiche, bass, pike, and pickerel, and other fish which are the object of the angler’s pursuit. The book is profusely illustrated with pictures and serviceable diagrams.

“The book compresses into a moderate space a larger amount of
interesting knowledge about fish and fishing than any other
volume that has appeared this season.”--_Chicago Tribune._

“It gives, in simple language and illustrations, much that it
will be profitable for our boys to know before they begin to
lay out their money, and much information that will be useful
to them when they begin to go farther afield than their own
immediate local waters.”--_Outing._

“One of the handsomest, most practical, most informing books
that we know. The author treats his subject with scientific
thoroughness, but with a light touch that makes the book easy
reading.... The book should be the companion of all who go
a-fishing.”--_New York Mail and Express._

BY HEZEKIAH BUTTERWORTH.

Uniform Edition. Each, 12mo, cloth.

=In the Days Of Audubon.= A Tale of the “Protector of Birds.”
Illustrated by B. West Clinedinst and Others. $1.20 net;
postage, 14 cents additional.

=In the Days Of Jefferson=; _or, The Six Golden Horseshoes_. A
Tale of Republican Simplicity. Illustrated by F. T. Merrill.
$1.50.

=The Story Of Magellan.= A Tale of the Discovery of the
Philippines. Illustrated by F. T. Merrill and Others. $1.50.

=The Treasure Ship.= A Story of Sir William Phipps and the
Inter-Charter Period in Massachusetts. Illustrated by B. West
Clinedinst and Others. $1.50.

=The Pilot of the Mayflower.= Illustrated by H. Winthrop Peirce
and Others. $1.50.

=True to his Home.= A Tale of the Boyhood of Franklin.
Illustrated by H. Winthrop Peirce. $1.50.

=The Wampum Belt=; _or, The Fairest Page of History_. A Tale of
William Penn’s Treaty with the Indians. With 6 full-page
Illustrations. $1.50.

=The Knight Of Liberty.= A Tale of the Fortunes of Lafayette.
With 6 full-page Illustrations. $1.50.

=The Patriot Schoolmaster.= A Tale of the Minutemen and the Sons
of Liberty. With 6 full-page Illustrations by H. Winthrop
Peirce. $1.50.

=In the Boyhood of Lincoln.= A Story of the Black Hawk War and
the Tunker Schoolmaster. With 12 Illustrations and colored
Frontispiece. $1.50.

=The Boys of Greenway Court.= A story of the Early Years of
Washington. With 10 full-page Illustrations. $1.50.

=The Log School-House on the Columbia.= With 13 full-page
Illustrations by J. Carter Beard, E. J. Austen, and Others.
$1.50.

FOR YOUNG READERS.

=Paleface and Redskin=,

And Other Stories for Boys and Girls. By F. ANSTEY, author of “Vice Versa,” etc.

=Christine’s Career.=

By PAULINE KING.

=John Boyd’s Adventures.=

By THOMAS W. KNOX.

=We All.=

By OCTAVE THANET.

=King Tom and the Runaways.=

By LOUIS PENDLETON.

=Englishman’s Haven.=

By W. J. GORDON.

=Along the Florida Reef.=

By CHARLES F. HOLDER.

Each, illustrated, 12mo, cloth, $1.50.

OUTDOOR BOOKS.

By RALPH HENRY BARBOUR.

Each, 12mo, cloth.

=Captain of the Crew.=

Illustrated by C. M. Relyea. $1.20 net; postage, 14 cents additional.

Mr. Barbour has made himself a master of sport in fiction for
young readers. His new book is one of those fresh, graphic,
delightful stories of school life that appeal to all healthy
boys and girls. He sketches skating and ice-boating and track
athletics, as well as rowing. His glimpses of training and his
brilliant picture of the great race will give this capital tale
an enduring popularity.

=For the Honor of the School.=

A Story of School Life and Interscholastic Sport. Illustrated by C. M. Relyea. $1.50.

“High spirits, good fellowship, and manliness breathe from its
pages.”--_The Outlook._

“A superior book for boys.... Enjoyable from cover to
cover.”--_Boston Congregationalist._

“A lively, spirited story, sure to interest boys, and
at the same time it is thoroughly wholesome and full of
information.”--_Boston Herald._

“It is a wholesome book, one tingling with health and activity,
endeavor and laudable ambition to excel in more fields than
one.”--_New York Mail and Express._

=The Half-Back.=

Illustrated by B. West Clinedinst. $1.50.

“It is a stirring, healthy boys’ book.”--_Philadelphia Call._

“A good, manly book for boys, on a good, manly Anglo-Saxon
game.”--_New York Mail and Express._

“It is in every sense an out-and-out boys’ book, simple
and manly in tone, hearty and healthy in its sports, and
full of that enthusiasm, life, and fondness for games which
characterize the wide-awake, active schoolboy.”--_Boston
Herald._

A UNIQUE BOOK.

“_For children, parents, teachers, and all who are interested in the psychology of childhood._”

=The Book of Knight and Barbara=.

By DAVID STARR JORDAN. Illustrated. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

The curious and fascinating tales and pictures of this unique book are introduced by Dr. Jordan with the foil owing preface: “The only apology the author can make in this case is that he never meant to do it. He had told his own children many stories of many kinds, some original, some imitative, some travesties of the work of real story-tellers. Two students of the department of education in the Stanford University--Mrs. Louise Maitland, of San Jose, and Miss Harriet Hawley, of Boston--asked him to repeat these stories before other children. Miss Hawley, as a stenographer, took them down for future reference, and while the author was absent on the Bering Sea Commission of 1896 she wrote them out in full, thus forming the material of this book. Copies of the stories were placed by Mrs. Maitland in the hands of hundreds of children. These drew illustrative pictures, after their fashion; and from the multitude offered, Mrs. Maitland chose those which are here reproduced. The scenes in the stories were also subjected to the criticisms of the children, and in many cases amended to meet their suggestions. These pictures made by the children have been found to interest deeply other children, a fact which gives them a definite value as original documents in the study of the workings of the child-mind. At the end of the volume are added a few true stories of birds and of beasts, told to a different audience. With these are a few drawings by university students, which are intended to assist the imagination of child-readers.”

BY CYRUS TOWNSEND BRADY.

=The Quiberon Touch.=

A Romance of the Sea. With frontispiece. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

“A story to make your pulse leap and your eyes
glisten. It fairly glows with color and throbs with
movement.”--_Philadelphia Item._

“This story has a real beauty; it breathes of the sea. Fenimore
Cooper would not be ashamed to own a disciple in the school of
which he was master in these descriptions of the tug of war as
it was in the eighteenth century between battle-ships under
sail.”--_New York Mail and Express._

=Commodore Paul Jones.=

A new volume in the GREAT COMMANDER SERIES, edited by General James Grant Wilson. With Photogravure Portrait and Maps. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50 net; postage, 11 cents additional.

“A thousand times more interesting than any of the so-called
historical romances that are now in vogue.”--_Spirit of the
Times._

“Mr. Brady’s vigorous style, vivid imagination, and dramatic
force are most happily exhibited in this book.”--_Philadelphia
Press._

“Incomparably fine. Being the work of a scholarly writer, it
must stand as the best popular life yet available. The book is
one to buy and own. It is more interesting than any novel, and
better written than most histories.”--_Nautical Gazette._

=Reuben James.=

A Hero of the Forecastle. A new volume in the YOUNG HEROES OF OUR NAVY SERIES. Illustrated by George Gibbs and Others. 12mo. Cloth, $1.00.

“A lively and spirited narrative.”--_Boston Herald._

“Mr. Brady has made a stirring tale out of the material before
him, one of those brilliant and forceful descriptions of the
glories of the old wooden-walled navy, which stir the blood
like a trumpet call.”--_Brooklyn Eagle._

RECENT FICTION.

=Kate Bonnet.=

The Romance of a Pirate’s Daughter. By FRANK R. STOCKTON, author of “Rudder Grange,” “The Lady or Tiger,” etc. Illustrated, 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

“A cleverly conceived and neatly developed story into which
Stockton has injected a goodly portion of his peculiarly
fantastic genius.... It has not a dull page.”--_Boston
Advertiser._

=Love in Its Tenderness.=

By J. R. AITKEN. 12mo. Cloth, $1.00; paper, 50 cents.

“It reminds us of Ian Maclaren, yet Mr. Aitken has traits
peculiarly his own.”--_London Echo._

“An unstudied pathos and charm and radiant simplicity pervade
the book.”--_London Daily News._

=Scarlet and Hyssop.=

By E. F. BENSON, author of “Dodo,” “Mammon & Co.,” “The Luck of the Vails,” etc. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

Mr. Benson has returned to the field which he developed with
such signal success in “Dodo,” and his new novel reveals a
brilliancy, social knowledge and worldly wisdom that show how
much the author has grown in force and pungency since the
appearance of his first book.

=The Strength of the Weak.=

By CHAUNCEY C. HOTCHKISS, author of “Betsy Ross,” “In Defiance of the King,” etc. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50.

“Mr. Hotchkiss firmly sustains the excitement of his story
at a pitch that holds the attention of the reader strongly
in eager anticipation without wearying him from excessive
vigor.”--_Baltimore Herald._

=A Fool’s Year.=

By E. H. COOPER. 12mo. Cloth, $1.00; paper, 50 cents.

“A well-written book with obvious marks of unusual
culture.”--_New York Commercial Advertiser._

A PICTURESQUE BOOK OF THE SEA.

=A Sailor’s Log.=

_Recollections of Forty Tears of Naval Life._ By Rear-Admiral ROBLEY D. EVANS, U. S. N. Illustrated. Large 12mo. Cloth, $2.00.

“It is essentially a book for men, young and old; and
the man who does not enjoy it is lacking in healthy red
blood.”--_Chicago Bookseller._

“A profoundly interesting book. There is not a line of bravado
in its chapters, nor a carping criticism. It is a book which
will increase the esteem and high honor which the American
feels and willingly awards our naval heroes.”--_Chicago
Inter-Ocean._

“It would be difficult to find an autobiography possessing more
interest than this narrative of forty years of active naval
service. It equals the most fascinating novel for interest;
it contains a great deal of material that has a distinct
historical value.... Altogether it is a most delightful
book.”--_Brooklyn Eagle._

“His is a picturesque personality, and he stands the supreme
test by being as popular with his officers and men as he is
with the public generally. His life has been one of action and
adventure since he was a boy, and the record of it which he has
prepared in his book ‘A Sailor’s Log’ has not a dull line in it
from cover to cover. It is all action, action, and again action
from the first page to the last, and makes one want to go and
‘do things’ himself. Any boy between fifteen and nineteen
who reads this book and does not want to go to sea must be a
sluggish youth.... The book is really an interesting record of
an interesting man.”--_New York Press._

D. APPLETON AND COMPANY, NEW YORK.

Transcriber’s Notes

Punctuation, hyphenation, and spelling were made consistent when a predominant preference was found in this book; otherwise they were not changed.

Simple typographical errors were corrected; occasional unbalanced quotation marks retained.

Ambiguous hyphens at the ends of lines were retained.

End of Project Gutenberg's With The Flag In The Channel, by James Barnes